Featured in American Thinker, November 2026
A worker’s vote to join a union should never become a blank check for someone else to decide the terms of that worker’s livelihood.
Yet Congress is advancing legislation that could leave employees living under a first union contract they never had an opportunity to approve, and employers bound by terms they never accepted.
The Faster Labor Contracts Act, H.R. 5408, passed the House on June 9. Its promise is appealing: help newly unionized workplaces reach their first contracts sooner. But the mechanism deserves far more scrutiny than its name suggests.
Under the House-passed bill, bargaining would generally begin within 10 days of a written request. After 90 days without agreement, either side could request federal mediation. If another 30 days passed without agreement, the dispute would move to binding arbitration, unless the parties agreed to more time.
A three-person panel would settle the dispute. The employer and union would each select a member and jointly choose a neutral member, with federal appointments filling vacancies if the selection process failed. The resulting decision would bind the parties for two years unless they agreed in writing to amend it.
The bill does not require workers to ratify that decision.
Supporters argue that employees who vote for representation should not have to wait indefinitely for a first contract. That concern deserves a serious response. Employers and unions alike should bargain honestly, and unlawful obstruction should have consequences.
But a deadline does not make an imposed agreement a good agreement.
Voting for union representation and approving the terms of a contract are different decisions. Workers may want collective representation while disagreeing with a particular arrangement governing compensation, benefits, or working conditions. Congress should protect their opportunity to judge the outcome.
The bill would allow an arbitration award to take effect without that safeguard. That is a troubling omission in legislation presented as empowering employees.
For small businesses, the consequences could extend well beyond a negotiating table.
An employer may be balancing rising insurance premiums, seasonal revenue, customer contracts, and the cost of keeping experienced employees. A commitment that appears manageable today can become difficult to sustain when a major customer leaves or operating expenses rise.
The legislation directs arbitrators to consider financial circumstances and other factors. That is appropriate. It cannot eliminate the risk that an imposed agreement will create obligations a business struggles to carry.
Workers share that risk. When commitments outpace a company’s resources, hiring, hours, investment, and benefits can all come under pressure.
As president of Christian Employers Alliance, I also see a question of stewardship. Christian employers are called to treat workers with dignity, pay fairly, and honor their commitments. Employees are people made in God’s image, with families and responsibilities of their own. Their well-being belongs at the center of workplace decisions.
Employers also bear responsibility for sustaining the enterprise and honoring its mission. Those responsibilities require room for careful judgment and meaningful negotiation.
For covered employers with religious commitments, disputes involving benefits or workplace policies can raise additional questions of conscience. Existing religious protections remain relevant, but Congress should examine how compulsory arbitration would interact with those protections before expanding this authority.
Lawmakers of both parties should apply the same test: Does this proposal strengthen the voice of the people who will live with the result?
Congress can encourage timely bargaining, support mediation, and enforce good-faith obligations while preserving consent. It should reject compulsory first-contract arbitration and protect workers’ opportunity to approve their contracts.
A faster contract is no victory if the people bound by it lose their say.
Read the original at American Thinker
Margaret Iuculano is president of the Christian Employers Alliance and founder of the Biblical Business Index (BBI), a framework evaluating federal and state public policy through biblical principles. Her central policy priority is calling on lawmakers to review every bill for its impact on religious freedom, conscience, and protections under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act before voting. CEA’s Before You Vote declaration advances this commitment alongside its Five Freedoms framework.